Effective Versus Ineffective Parenting: Know the Difference?

Many parents feel that if their children have food to eat, a safe place to sleep, and clothing to wear, then they are parenting well. However, this is only meeting the basic needs of children.

Parenting is a much more in-depth and committed relationship. The danger of ineffective parenting is that children are left at the mercy of life, predators, and childhood inexperience.

What is effective or ineffective parenting?

Because ineffective parenting is difficult to define, we will use effective parenting as a plum line to discuss the concept.

Effective parenting:

  • is defined as the ability to interact and engage with children in such a way that they learn and grow into remarkable adults.
  • takes daily effort to connect with children on a meaningful and personal level.

 
The major reason that most parents have become ineffective is because parents have relegated their children to quality time. Effective parenting demands both quality and quantity of time spent with children.

Many people often go to the other extreme by making children their #1 priority. Children cannot handle the pressure of that kind of commitment. It is better to keep things in balance and to put children in line after self-care and important adult relationships.

the word ineffective with in crossed outIt is important for parents to realize that effective parenting is seen both in childhood and in the adults their children become. However, the most effective determination of good parenting is that children in turn become good parents. Thus, effective parenting is best seen in what kind of parents the children become.

  • Children of effective parents are more likely to have an understanding of the world and what is expected of them as adults.
  • The children of ineffective parents rarely have the skills needed as they enter adulthood. They find themselves on a steep learning curve as they leave high school and move into the adult world.

Are you an effective parent?

The following six questions will give you a snapshot of your parenting tendencies.
 

  1. Can your children predict with great accuracy what will happen as a result of their misbehavior?
  2.  

  3. In your arsenal of parenting tools, do you have light, medium, and heavy consequences?
  4.  

  5. Do you spend time each day with your children engaging in meaningful activity or conversation?
  6.  

  7. Do you take time to talk through misunderstandings and misbehaviors when you are calm and level-headed?
  8.  

  9. Are you focused on helping your children become adults who can face the world competently?
  10.  

  11. Are you living the example that you want your children to meet and exceed in their future lives?
    If you answered “yes” to four or more of these questions, then you are moving in the right direction to become an effective parent.
     
    If you answered “yes” to three or less, then your parenting needs work.

Ineffective parenting is detrimental to children because it hampers them from moving into adulthood fully prepared. Most parents love their children and have no intention of hurting them. Yet many children lack the intimate and personal interactions needed to support future development. The issue is understanding what is and is not effective.
 

Effective versus Ineffective Parenting

Looking at the six questions above let us compare how effective and ineffective parents tend to behave.

  1. Can your children predict with great accuracy what will happen as a result of their misbehavior?

    • Effective parents discuss the rules with their children and make sure that they understand the expectations. They also make sure that consequences are understood and follow through with them no matter how they are feeling. In addition, effective parents help children to see that they chose the consequence by their behavior.
    •  

    • Ineffective parents tend to assume that children understand expectations. Parents often forget the rule themselves or enforce them sporadically. Children often walk on eggshells, afraid to make a mistake. This anxiety can affect both self-esteem and self-confidence.

  2. In your arsenal of parenting tools, do you have light, medium, and heavy consequences?

    • Effective parents keep a variety of tools at hand. They recognize that children make mistakes and that this is different from deliberate disobedience. These parents use mistakes as teaching tools to help children remember what is expected.

      They also see willful disobedience as needing to be met head-on. They do not allow children to overtly challenge their parental authority; however, they recognize that children challenge rules as a way to test the boundaries. Therefore, the punishment, while certain and swift, is also loving, kind, and sympathetic to the plight of the child.

    •  

    • Ineffective parents tend to see any kind of misbehavior as willful and manipulative. They often feel that the child is somehow trying to deliberately do something to hurt them. They fail to see degrees in misbehavior and only discipline their children when they have had enough of their “mess.”

      These parents tend to want to make their children feel badly about what they have done and browbeat them.. They can fail to realize that these negative feelings become how children see themselves, thus creating poor self-images and an inner sense of failure.

  3. Do you spend time each day with your children engaging in meaningful activity or conversation?

    • Effective parents tend to make time each day to make meaningful connections with their children. It becomes a priority to be a part of their children’s everyday world. It is very important for them to have loving and nurturing activities and conversations with their children whether they are playing a board game, reading together, making dinner, or just hanging out. Effective parents enjoy spending time with their children.
    •  

    • Ineffective parents tend to let days go by without any meaningful contact between them and their children. Parents interact with their children by a series of orders and corrections. The time of loving and fun interactions is rare and often laced with disappointment for both parent and child. These parents often feel guilty about not taking time with their children and tend to ply children with gifts of an extravagant nature to soothe their own feelings of guilt.
  4.  

  5. Do you take time to talk through misunderstandings and misbehaviors with your children when you are calm and level-headed?

    • Effective parents take the opportunity to use times of misbehavior and mistakes as teaching tools. They discuss the expectations and help kids to step back and look at their motives and hidden reasons for their misbehavior. They keep responsibility for the actions on their children and help children come up with strategies to prevent future problems. Their goal is for their children to develop inner control.
    •  

    • Ineffective parents tend to blame themselves for their children’s issues. If a child misbehaves, it becomes about their lack of parenting skills and not about the child’s mistakes or hidden reasons for the misbehavior. These parents tend to come down on children based on their feelings about the incident and not based on how they can help their children develop self-control.
  6.  

  7. Are you focused on helping your children become adults who can face the world in competently?

    • Effective parents recognize that the true test of parenting is in the adults their children become. They realize that children tend to take detours along the path and they need to make allowances. They stay focused on helping children learn from mistakes and help them to use the new learning. They are more concerned with the final person their children become rather than the bumps in the road.
    •  

    • Ineffective parents have difficulty separating their children’s behavior from who they are. They believe that it is imperative for children to behave to show that they are good parents. Many parents are concerned with how their children’s behavior reflects on them. They demand that children tow the line and behave.

      Yet, the parent’s authority and power are the motivators of good behavior and not the children’s own inner sense of control. Parents are more concerned with the here-and-now and fail to realize that their children often spend time in late teens and early adult years engaging in risky behavior and being unfocused because they have not developed a sense of inner control.

  8.  

  9. Are you living the example that you want your children to meet and exceed in their lives?

    • Effective parents recognize that they are the examples their children will base their lives upon. They also know that behavior speaks louder than words. They live out each day as the person they want their children to be in the future, recognizing that their children will often exceed them in life.
    •  

    • Ineffective parents, failing to recognize the example they are setting with their behavior,say things like “Don’t smoke” as they puff on a cigarette or “Don’t drink” while they sip vodka straight up. These parents think that telling children the right thing to do is an effective tool. In failing to live the life they want for their children, they are setting their children up to live the same way or worse as the years go by.
  10.  

    In Summary

    I hope that you can see the extreme differences in these two polar parenting styles. Most parents, about 80%, fall somewhere between the two extremes. However, the more you strive to be an effective parent the more it will benefit your children.

    Parenting is the toughest job you will ever love and hate. Recognizing your tendencies and making plans to overcome them is a great first step in becoming a more effective parent. Whether you find that your tendency is to be an effective or an ineffective parent, the truth is in parenting there is always room for improvement. So in the words of Nike: “Just Do It!!”

     

    By Barbara E. Harvey, Expert in Parent Development and Early Childhood

    Belief in Parenting

     

     ___________________________________________________________

     
    For more information about parenting, check out the following books. Purchasing books from our website through Amazon.com supports the work we do to help parents do the best job they can to raise their children.  A few of our favorites:

    Liberated Parents, Liberated Children by Faber and Mazlish Blessings of a Skinned Knee by Wendy Mogel The Whole Brain Child by Dan Siegel Parenting by Heart by Ron Taffel

    <recommended books about parenting

    <all our recommended parenting books

     

    If you found this article helpful, click here to make a donation to The Center for Parenting Education. Your support will enable us to continue to provide quality information free of charge.

     

    <return to top of page

    <additional articles that Focus on Parents

    <Library of Articles topic page